How Pink Floyd Fans Split Over the Post-Waters Era

Pink Floyd is an English rock band formed in London in 1965, with a legacy that spans over five decades and 15 studio albums. But the band’s history is also marked by a bitter and acrimonious split between its two main creative forces: Roger Waters and David Gilmour.

Roger Waters & Pink Floyd - Floydology Store
Roger Waters & Pink Floyd

Departure of Roger Waters

Waters, who was the band’s primary songwriter and conceptual leader, left Pink Floyd in 1985 after a legal dispute over the rights to the band’s name and music. He pursued a solo career and staged elaborate performances of his magnum opus, The Wall. Gilmour, who was the band’s lead guitarist and vocalist, continued to lead Pink Floyd with the remaining members, Nick Mason and Richard Wright, and released three more albums under the band’s name, as well as his own solo projects.

Reaction of Fans

The split between Waters and Gilmour divided Pink Floyd fans into two camps: those who followed Waters and considered him the true genius behind the band’s artistic vision, and those who supported Gilmour and appreciated his musical craftsmanship and melodic sensibility. The debate over who was the better musician, songwriter, or leader of Pink Floyd has been raging for decades, and has often turned into personal attacks and insults.

Some fans have tried to reconcile the two sides, arguing that both Waters and Gilmour contributed to the band’s greatness in different ways, and that their collaboration was what made Pink Floyd unique and innovative. They have also hoped for a reunion of the original lineup, which only happened once, in 2005, at the Live 8 concert for charity. Others have accepted the split as inevitable, given the creative differences and personality clashes between Waters and Gilmour, and have enjoyed their respective solo careers.

Pink Floyd’s Lasting Influence

Ultimately, whether one aligns with Team Waters, Team Gilmour, or seeks a harmonious coexistence of both perspectives, Pink Floyd’s legacy persists as a testament to the enduring power of their music. The band’s impact on the rock landscape remains unparalleled, and the ongoing dialogue surrounding their history reflects the profound connection fans maintain with this iconic ensemble.

This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.